A few months back, I got cocky.
See, I’d just watched a dozen LinkedIn influencers swear that SEO was dead and AI was the messiah. One guy even said he hadn’t written a single blog post in a year — he just fed prompts into ChatGPT and “let the money printer go brrr.”
So I thought: I’m a smart guy. I’ll try it too.
I opened up my laptop, took a sip of reheated coffee, and whispered something I’d never said before:
“Write a high-ranking blog post about digital marketing trends in 2025.”
And just like that, 800 words showed up. Fast. Slick. Grammar-perfect. I didn’t even have to think.
I slapped it into WordPress, hit publish, and imagined the traffic spike like it was a Super Bowl ad.
Then I waited.
And waited.
And waited some more.
The spike never came.
Turns out, I wasn’t alone.
A week later, a client forwarded me a post that sounded eerily familiar. Same tone. Same structure. Nearly the same title.
Written by a guy in Sweden.
And another in Kansas.
And one more in the Philippines.
Different blogs. Same robot author.
The AI Trap
That was the moment it hit me.
AI can write. Sure.
But it can’t remember what it felt like to pitch a client with sweaty palms.
It can’t tell the story of the time we split-test 14 subject lines to get a 1.5% lift.
It doesn’t know what it means to spend 6 months rebuilding a broken backlink profile by hand.
AI can summarize. It can suggest keywords.
But it doesn’t live the story.
It doesn’t earn the trust.
And trust? That’s still the currency of SEO.
What Still Works (and Always Will)
After my AI epiphany, I went back to the basics:
-
I pulled up Search Console and reviewed real search intent.
-
I updated my internal links like I was laying bricks.
-
I wrote a case study — from scratch — about a campaign that worked because we cared.
And the numbers?
They started moving again.
Not because I “prompt-engineered” magic.
But because I paired AI’s efficiency with real human empathy.
The Blend Is the Breakthrough
AI is a knife.
Sharp, useful, efficient.
But if you hand a knife to someone who’s never cooked, you get a mess — or worse, a trip to the ER.
Use AI to save time, not cut corners.
Let it help you brainstorm, summarize transcripts, or cluster keywords.
But let you be the one who tells the story.
You — with the scraped knees and late nights and wins that took 27 tries.
Because Google’s smarter than it used to be.
It doesn’t just want content. It wants proof.
And your experience? That’s proof.
Final Thought
If you remember anything from this story, make it this:
Don’t chase the hype. Build what lasts.
Let AI assist. But let you lead.
SEO isn’t dead.
But bland, soulless content is.
And honestly, that should’ve been obvious — because no AI would ever admit to drinking day-old coffee and thinking it was a good idea.